9 Rare American Girl Dolls That Could Be Worth $5,000

For more than 35 years, American Girl dolls have won the hearts of both children and adults with their expressive eyes and distinctive styles that celebrate the diversity of the real world — its colors, cultures, and stories.

But these dolls are more than just toys: certain rare editions have become highly sought-after collectibles, sometimes selling for thousands of dollars. From early versions with unique manufacturing quirks to fan-favorite characters that were retired too soon, here are nine valuable American Girl dolls that highlight the brand’s lasting charm and nostalgic appeal.

Original 1986 Kirsten

Kirsten is a treasured find for serious American Girl collectors, being one of the original three dolls launched in 1986. Early models of Kirsten dressed in her red-checked outfit and iconic braided hairstyle are particularly desirable.

When paired with original accessories like her St. Lucia crown, books, and school-themed items, the doll’s value can increase significantly. Although she was discontinued in 2010, collectors are still eager to own her. In fact, one fetched more than $6,000 at auction in 2021, and another is currently listed on eBay for close to $5,000.

White Body Samantha

Among the rarest versions of Samantha Parkington are those produced with white cloth bodies—an early feature that was later replaced with a tan torso. These earlier editions also came with noticeable design differences such as fuller lashes and a softer facial structure, making them highly collectible.

Since this version was only sold for about four years, they’re a tough find today. A pristine model can go for $400 or more, while even used versions still attract offers in the $200-plus range from eager collectors.

Josefina Montoya

Introduced in 1997, Josefina Montoya quickly captured hearts with her delicate features and large, soulful brown eyes. Though she was warmly received, she wasn’t produced in massive numbers, which adds to her current rarity.

If she’s accompanied by her original outfit and paperwork, she can fetch close to $600, and sometimes even more if in pristine condition with her original packaging. Her appeal lies in her authentic Southwestern style and historical significance, making her a gem for fans and collectors alike.

Cécile Rey

Cécile Rey, best friend to fellow doll Marie-Grace, is a standout figure among discontinued American Girl characters. Released as part of a duo, she was only sold for a short span of three years, ending in 2014. Her richly textured curls and lavish Victorian attire make her highly distinctive.

Due to her limited run, new-in-box Cécile dolls have become rare and sought-after, with current listings showing prices reaching $480. Despite her initial under-the-radar presence, she’s now a favorite in the resale market.

Caroline Abbott

Released in 2012, Caroline was part of the BeForever collection and represented the War of 1812 era. Her eye-catching pink and nautical-themed attire and intricate hairstyle set her apart.

Caroline didn’t stay on shelves for long, adding to her rarity and collectibility. Dolls that come with her full accessory set and are in good condition tend to sell for about $100, while those in unopened boxes or near-mint condition have gone for upwards of $500. Her historical theme and style keep her in high demand.

Limited-Edition Ruthie

Ruthie Smithens, the charming friend of Kit Kittredge, was only available for a single year before being retired in 2008. Her collection of Depression-era accessories, including her stylish mini purse and classic wristwatch, adds a unique flair.

Though she didn’t receive much attention initially, collectors now consider her highly desirable. Even secondhand Ruthie dolls can command more than $250, and boxed versions in like-new condition have recently sold for over $400, particularly among fans who value her era and design.

Limited Edition #21

Doll #21 from the “Girl of Today” series was part of a special release in 2009, featuring a unique combination of blonde hair, freckles, and deep brown eyes.

Her distinct look and limited availability make her a favorite among collectors. She was not restocked after the initial batch, which significantly boosted her rarity. Nowadays, collectors are willing to pay around $100 for her, especially if she comes complete with accessories or is still in her original packaging. Her charm lies in her rarity and unique design.

Marisol Luna

Marisol Luna, introduced in 2005 as the first Hispanic “Girl of the Year,” was a one-year release that left a lasting impression. Known for her vibrant dance-themed wardrobe and long, glossy dark hair, she quickly became a favorite among young fans and collectors.

Due to her short availability and cultural impact, complete and well-kept Marisol dolls are valued at over $500 in resale markets. Her popularity hasn’t waned, and boxed versions are especially appealing to those looking for standout characters.

German Samantha

When American Girl dolls were briefly distributed in West Germany, Samantha was among the select few to be released overseas with unique packaging and subtle tag changes. These German-market editions are nearly identical to their American counterparts, except for the small label indicating they were made for Germany.

Because only a limited number were produced, they’ve become incredibly hard to find. Currently, collectors are willing to spend more than $700 for one of these rare international versions, especially if they’re in excellent condition.