6 Rare State Quarter Coins Worth $267 Million Still Found in Circulation

Surprisingly, six rare state quarter varieties have a combined estimated market value of around $267 million—and they can still occasionally be found in circulation today.

These coins are highly sought after due to rare minting errors, limited production numbers, or unique characteristics. As a result, they’ve become hidden treasures from the U.S. Mint’s popular 50 State Quarters program. In some cases, these exceptional coins have fetched tens of thousands or even millions of dollars at auctions.

Now, both seasoned collectors and casual coin enthusiasts are searching through their change jars, hoping to discover one of these valuable pieces. Let’s take a closer look at the six rare state quarters that could turn spare change into an incredible financial windfall.

1999-P Delaware Spitting Horse Quarter

Among the most recognized error quarters is the 1999-P Delaware Spitting Horse Quarter, known for its distinctive die crack from the horse’s mouth, creating the illusion that it’s “spitting.”

Although it may sound peculiar, this unique flaw has made the coin highly desirable to collectors. Depending on its state of preservation, this quarter can sell for anywhere from $100 to $500, while mint-condition pieces can command prices exceeding $1,000.

As one of the earliest releases in the 50 State Quarters series, this coin holds nostalgic value for many collectors. If you notice a small line or “spit” appearing to emerge from Caesar Rodney’s horse, you might just be in possession of a numismatic gem.

2004-D Wisconsin Extra Leaf High Quarter

The 2004-D Wisconsin State Quarter gained fame due to its “Extra Leaf” error, where an additional leaf appears on the corn stalk. There are two variations of this mistake—”High Leaf” and “Low Leaf”—both of which are highly coveted by collectors.

The High Leaf version is significantly rarer and can fetch between $3,000 and $6,000, depending on its quality. Even circulated examples hold substantial value. This unusual flaw occurred due to accidental die gouges during minting, making each flawed coin a rare and valuable find.

2004-D Wisconsin Extra Leaf Low Quarter

While not as valuable as the High Leaf version, the Low Leaf Wisconsin Quarter is still a noteworthy collector’s item. In circulated condition, these coins often sell for $500 to $1,500, and coins in exceptional shape can attract even higher prices.

Error coins like these are particularly appealing to collectors, especially when the flaws are noticeable and dramatic. If you come across a coin with an extra leaf lower on the corn stalk, you could have stumbled upon a profitable minting error.

2000-P South Carolina Off-Center Strike Quarter

Another intriguing error coin is the 2000-P South Carolina Quarter, known for its off-center strike. This type of flaw occurs when the coin is not correctly aligned during the minting process, resulting in a shifted design.

The value of off-center strike quarters varies based on the degree of misalignment. Coins with significant but still visually complete misstrikes can be worth between $1,000 and $3,000 or more. Quarters with noticeable shifts but intact key features are especially valuable. If a South Carolina quarter in your collection appears misaligned, it may be worth a second look.

2001-P Vermont Double Die Reverse Quarter

Double die errors are always in high demand, and the 2001-P Vermont Quarter featuring a double die reverse is no different. You might notice doubled details in the trees, the sap gatherer figure, or the inscriptions.

Well-preserved double die examples can range in value from $750 to over $2,000. To spot this error, carefully examine Vermont quarters, focusing on fine elements like lettering and tree branches. Identifying this mistake could mean you’ve found a lucrative collectible.

1999-P Connecticut Broadstruck Quarter

The 1999-P Connecticut Broadstruck Quarter showcases a broadstruck error, where the coin is minted without a restraining collar, causing it to appear wider and flatter than typical quarters. The error is visually striking and relatively easy to recognize.

Depending on the extent of the distortion and the coin’s condition, these quarters can command prices between $500 and $2,500. The Connecticut quarter’s intricate Charter Oak tree design makes any stretching or flattening quite noticeable. Collectors value these flawed coins highly due to their unique appearance and rarity.

FAQs

Conclusion: A Hidden Treasure Could Be in Your Pocket

Imagine finding one of these rare state quarters in your change—it could be life-changing. Collectively valued at over $267 million, these coins are among the most coveted collectibles from the 50 State Quarters series.

The next time you receive a quarter, take a moment to examine it closely—you might just discover a priceless piece of history. Happy coin hunting!